Logo
Lovejoy Surgicenter
ISSUE #33.12 • NEWS • COLUMN
Rogue of the Week

Plastic Bottle Manufacturers

Social bookmarking | Permalink
Email | Print | Rate It! | 1 comment
Recently in "Rogue of the Week"

October 8th, 2008
Cynthia Harris | There’s wrong. Then there’s Army wrong.7 comments

October 1st, 2008
You Can’t Spell “Obsession” Without The O. | A new way to spark reader interest: Distribute a DVD that PO’s subscribers.15 comments

September 24th, 2008
Multnomah County Assessment & Taxation | Squeezing blood from a cucumber.13 comments

September 17th, 2008
David Powell7 comments

September 10th, 2008
John Nelsen | Truth in advertising?6 comments

September 3rd, 2008
Mayor Tom Potter | Fool me twice.8 comments

August 27th, 2008
Sue Castner | Serious Party Foul.28 comments

August 20th, 2008
Vladimir Putin | Georgia on our mind10 comments

August 13th, 2008
Clear Channel Outdoor | Company shows signs of cowardice.12 comments

August 6th, 2008
Senate Republicans | Thanks for nothing.2 comments


BY WW EDITORIAL STAFF | newsdesk at wweek dot com

[January 31st, 2007] We give this week's Rogue, plastic bottle manufacturers who do business in Oregon, an A for effort but an F for execution.

A Jan. 2 state report reveals that Oregon's recycling rate for rigid plastic containers fell to 24.3 percent in 2005, and is projected to remain below the state's 25-percent requirement. That marks the first time Oregon's recycling rate for rigid plastic containers has fallen below the 25 percent minimum since the law was established a decade ago. The consequence, under state rules: It's largely up to manufacturers to address the problem.

But manufacturers blame Oregon's commingled recycling, which allows consumers to mix recyclables, resulting in wasteful sorting of recyclable materials.

"When it's the failure of the system to actually achieve the recycling of the materials that are actually put out on the curb, it doesn't seem just to be holding the product manufacturers and consumers responsible," says Pat McCormick, a spokesman for manufacturers such as the Grocery Manufacturers of America.

The manufacturers' Roguish solution?

A semantic stunt that petitions the Department of Environmental Quality to "redefine" what it means to recycle in Oregon.













icon Story continues below

advertisement
OMSI
advertisement

DEQ estimates about 1,700 tons of rigid plastic containers left on the curbside for recycling aren't actually recycled but are instead "lost" in sorting.

The petition filed by 11 groups, including Associated Oregon Industries, proposes including that discarded waste in total recycling calculations. If that happened, voilà, the recycling rate could climb above 25 percent, though nobody has an exact figure.

So if Oregonians tried to recycle a bottle, but it still wound up in the landfill, technically, they still recycled it. Sounds a little fishy, right?

No doubt the state's commingled recycling system could be more efficient—but hey, the law's the law.

"The manufacturers that are responsible for this problem, instead of working toward real, physical solutions, proposed something much simpler, which is to move the goal posts," says Jeremiah Baumann, an environmental advocate for the Oregon State Public Interest Research Group. "Basically, this petition is absurd."

—Lance Kramer

Rate This Story
4 average/1 vote

 
read all 1 comments | add your comment
 

RECENT COMMENTS ON “Plastic Bottle Manufacturers”

1

Figures, any ways necessary to save a buck, never mind about; global warming, lack of space, energy crisis, pollution, etc. lets just look at the bottom line. I am a volunteer firefighter with one dep...

Sgt. FF/EMT Robert Christian, Feb 6th, 2007 1:02am
 
 
 





Recently in Willamette Week
October 12th 2008Unlucky Strike | The Oregon lottery is going into detox—and our state budget is along for the smoke-free ride.
October 12th 2008Jail Junkies | Who knows more about stopping property crime: Kevin Mannix or an ex-addict who stole 1,000 cars?
October 12th 2008Shipracked | Judy Shiprack wants to be your next county commissioner. Here’s what she doesn’t want you to know about a real-estate deal gone bad.
October 12th 2008Señor Smith | Low-wage Latino workers keep Sen. Gordon Smith’s family business humming. Not all of them are legal.
October 12th 2008OMFG IT'S MFNW!
October 12th 2008Sometimes a Great Lawsuit | Ken Kesey’s last prank pits his widow in a court battle with his best friend and a Playboy model.
October 12th 2008Sliced Bread, Beware | A better fire hose, a poker aid & a foldable clipboard—meet six Portland inventors whose big ideas are the best thing since, well, you know.
October 12th 2008How to Live Cheap in Portland | Throwing too much money away on food and shelter? here’s WW’s Recession Survival Guide.
October 12th 2008The Queer and the Qur’an | Ali is gay. And Muslim. Can he be both?