Bobby Heaukulani is the only detective in the nation investigating illegal dumps.
GARBAGE PATROL: Det. Bobby Heaukulani. - IMAGE: Darryl James
5 Comments
Tags:
Growing up on Army bases in the South, Bobby Heaukulani’s favorite TV show was Hill Street Blues. He liked to play with BB guns. When asked what he wanted to be when he grew up, he always said policeman.
When Heaukulani
(“Huk” for short) was 13, his dad got transferred to a military base in
Hawaii, the family’s ancestral home. There, Heaukulani got to spend time
with his uncle, who was on a fast rise through the Honolulu Police
Department—eventually retiring as assistant chief.
Huk grew into a
mountain of a man. He played fullback and linebacker in high school,
then got recruited as a tailback to Linfield College by legendary coach
Ad Rutschman. Oregon has been Heaukulani’s home ever since.
In 1989, he became a cop.
“The camaraderie, the
brotherhood, being in a job that benefits people. I know it sounds
hokey, but that’s why I got into it—to try to make the world a better
place,” says Heaukulani, 52.
For
12 years, he worked as a cop in Tigard. For his last 10 years, he
investigated crimes against children—mostly sex abuse by family members.
That assignment chews through most cops in a matter of a few years.
“He gained a
reputation all across the region as one of the very best at working
those kinds of cases,” says Tigard Police Lt. Erick Boothby, one of
Heaukulani’s former partners. “He’s the guy that will always do the
right thing.”
Four years ago, Huk burned out.
“For a long time I
didn’t take a vacation. When there’s children being hurt, you don’t feel
like you can take that time off,” says Heaukulani, who lives in Tigard
with his wife and two sons.
“I didn’t care about anything else but working my cases,” he says. “I thought, I’m holding on too tight here.”
So, three years ago,
he switched beats. Now, instead of fulfilling his childhood dream
busting murderers, he’s probably the only detective in America who works
full-time investigating illegal garbage dumping.
Discarded futons,
worn-out tires, construction debris and bags of household trash—that’s
the medium Huk has worked with for the past three years. When they’re
dumped on public property in the Portland metro area, his mission is to
track down the perpetrators and hit them with fines.
A sense of humor is de rigueur for a cop, whether he’s busting child abusers or finding serial litterers.
“I’ve heard people say, ‘You worked with garbage before, and you’re working with garbage now,’” Huk quips.
Metro's Top 10 Illegal Dumping Sites for 2010 Click on the Cop Icon for rank and details
The dumps Heaukulani
investigates range from the alarming to the seemingly innocuous—from
hazardous materials like paint and oil dumped into stream beds and other
environmentally sensitive areas, to old furniture abandoned on
neighborhood curbsides.
One extreme case came
on the night of April 29, 2009, when someone dumped more than 200 tires
along Northeast Marine Drive, all the way from 148th Avenue to Blue
Lake Park in Gresham. Metro officials say the tires were spaced every 10
to 15 feet along the roadside, as if they had been pushed out of a
moving vehicle. The case remains unsolved.
On the milder side of the spectrum lies Barak Hen.
In early June, Hen, a
34-year-old locksmith, made a costly mistake. After filling a dumpster
with unwanted items from a house he had recently purchased in Southeast
Portland, he put two couches and a plush chair that wouldn’t fit in the
dumpster in a vacant lot next door.
Hen’s attitude: The furniture was still in good condition. Eventually someone might take it.
His thoughtless trash
toss brought an orange-vested inmate work crew to clean up the mess.
Eventually, it led to a two-week investigation and a $404 citation from
Heaukulani.
When Heaukulani
caught up with Hen on a recent Monday afternoon outside the house on
Southeast Ramona Street, Hen admitted dumping the furniture but was
furious about the fine.
“I didn’t do anything wrong,” he insisted.
One month earlier,
Amy Stewart was equally outraged when Heaukulani questioned her about
using yard debris to fill a pothole on the unpaved city street outside
her house in Northeast Portland.
“The city won’t fill these potholes, and when we do, the police come? Unbelievable,” Stewart says.
In a moment of mercy, Huk let her off without a fine.
ALLEY CATS: Multnomah County Deputy Gordon Glasser supervises inmates Byron Brown and Yordan Araujo-Coppinger cleaning up an illegal dump in a North Portland alley.
Credits: Darryl James
Bespectacled and walking with a slight hunch, Steve Kraten
has the soft voice, shy demeanor and tendency to slip into bureaucratic
speak that mark him as a 22-year employee of the Metro regional
government.
As
the agency’s longtime solid-waste enforcement coordinator, Kraten
remembers how Metro became the only agency in the country that actively
investigates trash dumpers.
Among
other duties, Metro is in charge of disposing of the region’s garbage.
It regulates transfer stations and recycling centers, and collects fees
to help pay for it all. In 1993, revenue from those fees was dropping.
Officials figured
more people were dodging Metro’s trash-disposal system—mainly
contractors. So they started a program aimed at increasing Metro’s
so-called flow control over the trash stream, though they were smart
enough not to call it that.
“Flow control is kind of an esoteric thing,” Kraten says. “Illegal dumping is something that people can understand.”
Today
it’s called RID Patrol, which stands for Regional Illegal Dumping.
Metro officials say it’s the only program of its kind in America. Other
places have tried to reduce illegal dumping, but Metro officials believe
no other government agency has detectives like Heaukulani working to
investigate dumps and track down the culprits.
The
program cleans up more than 2,000 illegal dumps a year and costs
taxpayers about $500,000 a year. That money goes to pay for Metro
administrative salaries, disposal fees, maintaining two cleanup trucks,
and paying the salaries of three detectives and two jail deputies who
supervise the inmate work crews that clean up the dumps.
Two other detectives
police construction sites and other large-scale waste producers. Relying
on snitches and evidence collected by jail crew members—some of it
highly personal—Heaukulani tracks down about 60 illegal small-time
dumpers each year, hitting them with fines of up to $500, plus the cost
of the cleanup and disposal. The latter can amount to hundreds of
dollars, or more in extreme cases.
Since Heaukulani
starting working the trash beat in 2008, he has written around 200
citations for a total of more than $72,000. But less than half of that
actually gets collected by Metro. The rest goes to a collections agency.
Kraten says the
program wasn’t intended to be a money-maker in itself. Its purpose is to
enhance Metro’s income from legitimate garbage disposal.
It’s hard to imagine a
more Portlandesque program than this: Police are used to track down
environmental ne’er-do-wells—all in an effort to boost the government’s
ability to collect money.
But besides
bolstering Portland’s nanny-state tendencies, the RID patrol also
exemplifies some of our best qualities—few places take garbage and its
environmental impacts as seriously as we do.
Although the
Legislature this year whiffed on passing what would have been America’s
first statewide ban on plastic grocery bags, Portland consistently ranks
No. 1 in the nation among green cities—partly for our robust recycling
program and consistently high recycling rate.
The RID program
sparks controversy among those who are caught in its web. But rest
assured: If you dump trash, Heaukulani and his team will be out to nail
you. And their tactics may raise some eyebrows.
MATTRESS WORLD: Inmates haul away a dumped mattress near Lone Fir Cemetery in Southeast Portland.
Credits: Darryl James
Metro’s fleet includes two heavy-duty pickups with
trash-hauling trailers hitched to the back. Each transports a two-man
inmate work crew and a jail deputy. They show up at reported trash sites
or, lacking those, cruise around to the region’s repeat dumping
grounds.
If a
dump’s on public land, they throw the trash into the trailer and haul
it to a transfer station. (They don’t clean dumps on private land using
taxpayer dollars.) The deputies record GPS coordinates for each dump, as
well as the size and the time it takes to clean up. Those factor into
the fine.
Inmates search the
trash for any evidence to identify the owner. That often includes
unopened mail, unpaid bills, catalogs with a street address or
prescription pill bottles. More unusual examples have included computer
hard drives.
“My favorite: fully
completed job applications. We’ve gotten a few of those,” says Tiffany
Gates, assistant solid waste planner at Metro.
To date, there has
been no testing for fingerprints on old tires or DNA from mattresses.
“Give us a grant and we’ll do it,” Gates says.
The evidence goes to
Heaukulani, who builds a case and tracks down the owners of the trash.
They often blame a third party they say either stole their garbage or
was paid to haul it to a landfill.
If
those haulers can be found, they sometimes get cited. But they often
never even exist. And regardless of excuse, the citations usually go to
the trash’s original owners. They get three weeks to make a payment plan
or schedule an administrative hearing.
Metro has learned some lessons in the 18 years it’s run the program.
Some are curiosities.
January and June are the worst months for illegal dumping. People get
rid of their unwanted stuff after the holidays and during the first warm
weekends of spring.
Others are more
sinister. Thieves have stolen every surveillance camera Metro has set up
in popular dump sites to catch polluters.
Metro
has two tips for residents who don’t want to be slapped with a fine for
dumping. Don’t pay anyone to haul your trash unless you know who they
are, and they agree to provide a receipt from the landfill. And don’t
dump your old couch on the curb.
People leaving their
furniture on the street is a common problem. When they’re busted,
violators accuse Heaukulani of opposing sustainable re-use. Indeed, many
Portlanders tend to regard the practice of putting freebies on the curb
as a quirky part of the recycling culture. But Metro says it’s dumping,
plain and simple.
“I love re-use, but
we ask that you keep it on your porch and put it on Craigslist,” Gates
says. “It rains a lot in Portland, in case you haven’t noticed. As soon
as a sofa or mattress gets wet, believe me, nobody wants it.”
CHOP SHOP: Jail inmate Byron Brown prepares to cut up an armchair dumped near Southeast Powell Boulevard.
Credits: Darryl James
On a chilly Tuesday afternoon in mid-June, Byron Brown and
Yordan Araujo-Coppinger ride through town in a rig marked RID Patrol,
cleaning up illegal dumps for $1 a day.
Both men reside at
Inverness Jail. Brown is serving six months for driving under the
influence—his third DUII conviction. Araujo-Coppinger is doing 60 days
for violating a restraining order.
In a grassy field
near Portland International Airport, the two locate a dump reported the
day before by City of Portland workers: a discarded beige sofa, an empty
plastic suitcase, five car tires and a rust-stained mattress.
While
Araujo-Coppinger rolls the tires out of the waist-high grass, Brown uses
a curved-blade utility knife to attack the sofa, cutting it into pieces
that will fit in the truck. He also searches inside the sofa for
evidence of who left it.
Brown finds nothing
but a 1977 Mexican one-peso coin—“lunch money,” he says, slipping it
into the pocket of his khaki coveralls. The inmates who comb Portland’s
illegal dump sites for clues sometimes make juicier finds.
What
about those bank receipts, personal letters and hard drives? Metro
downplays any danger that inmates will misuse the information. The
inmates on trash detail are considered low-risk and receive time off
their sentences if they perform well.
Deputies say no
inmate has attempted to escape from garbage detail. But they have balked
at some tasks, such as cleaning up human waste, used needles, vomit and
feces at homeless camps.
“I always tell my
guys, ‘I’ll never have you do anything I wouldn’t do,’” says Deputy
Gordon Glasser. “But, unfortunately, I am in charge.”
TIRED OUT: Heaukulani tours RB Recycling in North Portland. Illegally dumped tires are some of his hardest cases.
Credits: Darryl James
Heaukulani starts most days in Metro
headquarters on Northeast Grand Avenue, where he picks out a handful of
the roughly 40 cases he has open at a given time. A file on his computer
is labeled “Huk’s Hit List”—five cold cases he still hopes to crack.
He starts by working
on the freshest reports, because people often dump trash as they’re
about to leave town. Combing law-enforcement databases, using Internet
searches and working the phones, he tries to connect clues from dumps to
the people behind them. He needs to build a case that will hold up at a
hearing.
“Mail
is the best. It’s hard to explain how your mail got into somebody
else’s garbage,” Heaukulani says. “Tires are the hardest. They’re almost
impossible to trace back.”
Two
unsolved dumps still gnaw at Heaukulani. Both are from 2008. In the
first, a man dumped a junky motorboat on Northeast Ainsworth Street. He
chained it to a stop sign and drove away in his rig, causing the boat to
fall off the trailer onto the road.
In
the second, a man left behind a used boat full of tires. Heaukulani had
secured a promise from the man to clean up the mess. Then he
disappeared.
“In 2008, I was still thinking it was OK to give people warnings,” Heaukulani says.
Heaukulani carries a
9-mm Glock 26 handgun. He has never been attacked investigating dumps.
But he says several suspects have become angry. Violence is always a
possibility.
“If I wasn’t such a big guy, I have no doubt some of those encounters would have turned out differently,” he says.
IAN SHULER: Took the blame for a dumped box spring.
Credits: James Pitkin
On a recent Monday
morning, he followed up on a report of a box spring dumped from a nearby
house. The neighbor described the dumpers as “skater kids” and said he
feared retaliation.
Heaukulani arrived at
2906 NE 63rd Ave. at 9:50 am. After repeated knocking, 22-year-old Ian
Shuler got off the couch and came to the door with a blanket wrapped
around him and sleep in his eyes.
“It’s unprecedented
for anyone to visit before noon,” said Shuler, adding he had just moved
to Portland because “South Carolina is terrible.”
Heaukulani showed him
a picture of the box spring. Shuler took a long pause, then admitted he
might recognize it. He went inside to consult two roommates.
“You see that little delay?” Heaukulani asked while Shuler was away. “That’s a basically honest person who is now panicking.”
Shuler returned and
said he’d take responsibility, because his roommates were playing dumb.
Heaukulani wrote him a $150 ticket—the least amount possible, but still
considerable given Shuler’s job as an usher at Regal Lloyd Center
Cinema.
“I’m gonna guess one night, someone was drunk and just dumped it,” Shuler said while Heaukulani wrote the ticket.
Later that day, Heaukulani cited Barak Hen for the furniture dump near his Southeast Portland home. Two tickets was a big win.
“There are days when I just beat the pavement and don’t get anything but leads,” Heaukulani says.
In 3
1/2 years on the Metro garbage beat, Heaukulani has found time off he
never felt he had working child crimes. He spends it with his wife and
sons. He’s active at St. Anthony’s Catholic Church and coaches football,
basketball and baseball.
But Heaukulani hopes to return to working child-abuse cases when he goes back to regular duty with Tigard Police in January.
“That’s where I feel like I can make the biggest impact,” he says.
No offense to Metro’s RID Patrol.
Photos Courtesy of Metro
The Dump Files
BENJAMIN CAPPS: Cited for illegal dumping.
Credits: James Pitkin
What sort of person would dump their trash? Consider these three RID Patrol cases from this year—and the reactions when WW tracked down the folks who were fined.
1.On May 25, the Oregon Department of Environmental Quality
reported an illegal dump of old paint cans on Southeast Evergreen
Street. An inmate work crew found an address written on one of the cans:
7030 SE 76th Ave.
Heaukulani
arrived at that address on June 3 and saw a man on a pink bicycle
leaving. Heaukulani found the resident, Mark Freimark. Freimark
recognized photos of the paint cans and said he’d hired a man to dispose
of the cans. Heaukulani had heard that story many times before and
often doubted it. But Freimark told Heaukulani the man he’d hired was
the guy on the pink bike.
Heaukulani
cruised the neighborhood and found David Hallstead, age 55—the man on
the pink bike. Hallstead told Heaukulani that Freimark had paid him $20
to get rid of the cans. Heaukulani fined him $300.
When WW caught
up with Hallstead, he was sitting on his porch in a red flannel shirt,
soiled jeans and a baseball cap. He said he makes a modest living doing
yard work for neighbors, adding he’s had to work harder to pay off the
fine.
As
he stared at the ground and kicked a plastic swan lying in his yard,
Hallstead insisted it was the first time he’d dumped illegally.
“It was a bad thing, and I learned my lesson,” Hallstead said. “That’s all I really have to say.”
2.On Feb. 4, an employee at Vernon Elementary School in
Northeast Portland emailed Metro to report someone had been placing
garbage in the school’s dumpster for three months. The school locks the
dumpster at night, but the person was prying up the lid. A custodian had
found a catalog addressed to 5216 NE 19th Ave.
Heaukulani called
Waste Management and learned that address has no garbage service.
Heaukulani arrived at the house and spoke with Walter Hudson, age 53.
Hudson admitted to dumping the trash and said he can’t afford garbage
service, according to Heaukulani’s report. Heaukulani fined Hudson $150.
When WW
knocked at Hudson’s house on a recent Sunday afternoon, he stepped
outside onto the porch. A social gathering was going on inside, and the
smell of marijuana smoke was in the air.
“I ain’t got no comment,” Hudson said.
3.On March 31, a Metro employee at the St.
Johns Landfill reported two separate dumps just off the Columbia Slough
boat ramp. The largest included garbage, tires, blue painted wood and
mail addressed to 7330 SE 113th Ave.
Nobody was home at
that address when Heaukulani arrived on April 7, but the wood garage was
the same color as the dumped wood and had new siding on the front. “It
was obvious,” Heaukulani wrote in his report, “that the dumped wood came
from this location.”
On
April 19, Heaukulani returned and showed homeowner Benjamin Capps
pictures of the dump. Capps agreed it was his trash and told Heaukulani
that he had sold a truck for scrap metal on the condition that the buyer
take the load of trash that was in the truck. Heaukulani fined him
$400.
WW caught up
with Capps, a retired parking-meter repairman for the City of Portland.
Capps said that at the time, he didn’t have garbage service because of a
bill dispute with Waste Management. After the dumping fine, he resumed
paying for trash service.
Capps admitted he had doubts about where the truck buyers would take the trash.
“I was like, oh man, I hope they don’t illegally dump that stuff,” Capps said.
Metro relies heavily on residents to report illegal dump sites. Call 234-3000 or go to oregonmetro.gov.
Remember this guy all too well, put out trash bags one night for morning pickup. Seems local vagrants grabbed the bags that night, did not find what they wanted and put them in a dumpster elsewhere. Got a call from this guy with threats of fines for illegal dumping. Even with a reasonable explanation I got the riot act from this maroon. Total power trip and the guy must hate his job and takes it out on everybody else.
Your story left out some key facts. Where was BoBo(we used to call him that) a cop in 1989 ? Certainly wasn't Tigard as he was a "Civil Deputy" for MCSO(they just serve papers) from about 1993-1999,, give or take, when he left S.O. for Tigard so maybe your article should have mentioned he became a cop in 1999, not 1989...He is one of the nicest guys you'd ever want to meet and a dream to work with...
So while there's a "trash cop" to hit [mostly poor people] up with hefty fines [city-sanctioned extortion] over what seems to be mostly mild offenses... where's the authorities to prosecute LARGE CORPORATIONS who dump MILLIONS OF TONS of trash, toxins, waste, and other garbage into the environment??? Why is there NO mention of that at all here? Trash is trash, right?
No 8x10 color glossies with the circles and arrows and the paragraph on the back?
Remember this guy all too well, put out trash bags one night for morning pickup. Seems local vagrants grabbed the bags that night, did not find what they wanted and put them in a dumpster elsewhere. Got a call from this guy with threats of fines for illegal dumping. Even with a reasonable explanation I got the riot act from this maroon. Total power trip and the guy must hate his job and takes it out on everybody else.
Wayyy over the top....
riiiigghht....maybe you should put your trash bags in a recepticle like the rest of us... sounds like you are the "maroon"
Your story left out some key facts. Where was BoBo(we used to call him that) a cop in 1989 ? Certainly wasn't Tigard as he was a "Civil Deputy" for MCSO(they just serve papers) from about 1993-1999,, give or take, when he left S.O. for Tigard so maybe your article should have mentioned he became a cop in 1999, not 1989...He is one of the nicest guys you'd ever want to meet and a dream to work with...
So while there's a "trash cop" to hit [mostly poor people] up with hefty fines [city-sanctioned extortion] over what seems to be mostly mild offenses... where's the authorities to prosecute LARGE CORPORATIONS who dump MILLIONS OF TONS of trash, toxins, waste, and other garbage into the environment??? Why is there NO mention of that at all here? Trash is trash, right?