Monday, February 13

UPDATED: Help S.F. Band Dominant Legs Recover Their Stolen Gear

Music Here's a story to make your music-loving blood boil: the fantastic San Francisco band Dominant Legs ... More

Feb 11, 2012 06:50 pm by ROBERT HAM  | Comments 1
 

Lackthereof (Menomena's Danny Seim) Releases Free EP

Music I don't have one of those little Daily Quotation calendars on my desk, but sometimes when I'm feelin... More

Feb 10, 2012 11:17 am by CASEY JARMAN  | Comments 0
 

Live Review: Wilco at Arlene Schnitzer Concert Hall (2/8/12)

Music Why does Wilco play the old stuff?That’s not rhetorical—it’s a genuine mystery to me, somethin... More

Feb 9, 2012 06:30 pm by Martin Cizmar  | Comments 6
 

Upper Extremities #26: From the Back of the Room Documentary (Q&A)

Music In the low-key and conversational documentary From the Back of the Room, which screens at the Know o... More

Feb 9, 2012 12:15 pm by CHRIS STAMM  | Comments 0
 
TOUR DIARY

Loch Lomond Tour Diary: Hearts on Fire (Big Sur/San Francisco)

Music This is the final installment of the Loch Lomond tour diary (going up a bit late). We'd like to than... More

Oct 10, 2011 10:40 am by Loch Lomond  | Comments 1
 

Loch Lomond: Bathroom Sipping is Not a Crime (Santa Barbara/Visalia)

Music Almost everything is bigger in California. We pulled into Santa Barbara to play the Mercury Lounge. ... More

Oct 3, 2011 04:30 pm by Loch Lomond  | Comments 1
 

Nurses: Martial Arts and Drug Dogs

Music This is the first entry in Nurses' tour diary. We are super-stoked to have them, no matter how brief... More

Oct 3, 2011 04:10 pm by Nurses  | Comments 0
 

Loch Lomond: Trampolines and Tecate (Long Beach/LA)

Music Leaving our beach day respite in Santa Cruz was difficult, but we managed to pull ourselves away, re... More

Sep 28, 2011 01:00 pm by Maggie Summers  | Comments 0
 
 
 
Home · Articles · Music · Here Comes Your Fan · Girl Power!
October 3rd, 2007 Amy Mccullough | Here Comes Your Fan
 

Girl Power!

Is being a woman all it takes to “rock”?

9 Comments
     
Tags:
In an interview earlier this year, local songwriter Morgan Grace had this to say about being a female musician: “The gender issue kinda pisses me off. It’s like, ‘Oh, you’re a female and you play guitar. Care to comment on that?’ No. I think our society has evolved to the point where those things are no longer novelty, and it fucking pisses me off.” I couldn’t have said it better myself.

In fact, Grace’s opinion could sum up why I’ve never written about being WW’s first female music editor: Doesn’t pointing out the fact that you’re a woman just mean you’re acknowledging some sort of difference? But Eric Kotila, founder of the Women Who Rock concert series (and, yes, a man), has a different outlook.

“I’ve been a musician in this town for a number of years,” says Kotila, an Oregon native. “Ninety percent of the bands I’ve been in have been female-fronted.” He also mentions that he grew up around musical women and found them inspirational. But the old-school rocker (dark hair, sideburns, black T-shirt) admits the project was “initially kind of a ploy to get more gigs” (a drummer, he occasionally plays with folk-rock band Bridge Creek). While that might make him sound like a smooth-talker, he seems honestly interested in helping female musicians gain exposure: “I’ve never told anyone, ‘You don’t fit in,’” he says. “The door’s open.”

While Kotila’s open policy sounds fine in theory, it calls to mind another problem that often accompanies “you go, girl” music collectives: Just because you’re a woman doesn’t mean you make good music. Kotila—who, along with girlfriend/roots musician Reina G. Collins, is working with female-centric arts and music fest Siren Nation (as treasurer and stage manager, respectively)—acknowledges that, “Yeah, there’s been a couple of ‘eh’” acts. But he also believes in giving everyone a chance.

And, because Kotila recently began booking for Mount Tabor Legacy, he now has more of a vehicle for doing so. WWR used to host monthly showcases at the White Eagle, Ash Street Saloon and the Green Room (as well as an acoustic night at Vino Vixens). Now he’s moved WWR solely to Mount Tabor Legacy, where it will take advantage of the venue’s layout, hosting acts in both its large room and its smaller, more songwriter-friendly lounge—and where Kotila also has an entire music calendar to fill.

When I ask whether WWR is exploiting “girls with guitars,” Kotila defends himself: “I’ve always been enthralled with the music first,” he says. “It worked this way because of the [bands] I was in.” When presented with Grace’s comments, he says, “There’s always gonna be a handful of people who say, ‘I just want respect for the music I do.’ And usually those are the people who have already earned it.” Now that’s something I can agree with.


SEE IT: Angela Davise, Gina Noell and Felina’s Arrow play a Women Who Rock benefit for Siren Nation Thursday, Oct. 4, at the White Eagle. 8:30 pm. $5. 21+. The Women Who Rock series takes place every first Saturday at Mount Tabor Legacy. See myspace.com/womenwhorockpdx for more info.
 
  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
 
 
 

 

 
10.03.2007 at 05:42 Reply
First of all, women do NOT have equality in the music industry, so from that perspective, having special forums for women to show their music helps open doors for women who might otherwise be overlooked or even discriminated against. Second, this is a CELEBRATION of women in the arts-just like the Siren Nation festival (www.sirennation.com) is. I'll support a celebration anyday, even if it pisses off the post-feminist watchdogs.

 

10.03.2007 at 05:47 Reply
First of all, there is still discrimination against women in the music industry. Anyone who thinks there isn't has their head buried in the sands of privelege. Forums like this that showcase women give women chances that are often reserved for white males. Second of all, this is a CELEBRATION of women-as is the Siren Nation festival (www.sirennation.org). I'll take a celebration anyday, even if it pisses off the post-feminist watchdogs.

 

10.03.2007 at 12:56 Reply
Nice article Amy. You hit both sides of this issue perfectly. I have gotten to know Eric over the past few years. He's always out on the Portland scene supporting musicians of all kinds. I think it's great that he has figured out a way to use his talents as a promoter/event planner to help the Portland scene and in particular show case the strong pack of female musicans that thrive here. I believe he has the interests of the musical community at heart and it's great that he takes time out to help Women Who Rock in particular. Hats off to Willie Week for acknowledging the issues and giving the man his due.

Pilar French

local musician

 

10.04.2007 at 02:35 Reply
I appreciate both Amy and Grace's points about not wanting to be identified or tokenized for being female in a male-dominated business. I think we all wish to appreciated for the work that we do, not because of or in spite of our gender. However, I wish Amy could recognize the value of creating spaces that put women front and center, especially in the music industry where women still so marginalized. I resent the insinuation that women-centered events mean that the quality will be compromised. Haven't you ever seen or heard an all-male band that sucked? Do you ever question why talentless men can get so far in the music industry? I can tell you that it is because it is easier to succeed as a man that as a woman. Women struggle to be taken seriously in the music industry, in journalism, and practically ever other professional field. I am sorry you are so eager to distance yourself from being a woman because it seems that you fear people will assume you are lesser because of it. Face it lady, you are different and will be treated as such. And that sucks. That is why festivals like Siren Nation were created---to celebrate and showcase the tremendous talent of the women of the Pacific Northwest. There are tons of great festivals in this town, but most of them are very heavy on the testosterone. I am quite confident that we have not compromised the quality of our festival by 'limiting' ourselves to booking female-fronted acts.

--Natalia Kay

Executive Director, Siren Nation: Celebrating Women, Art, & Community

 

10.04.2007 at 06:38 Reply
What's great about what Eric, Amy, Reina, Hal, Morgan, Natalia, Beth, Lisa & BC, Andie, Jen & her Ex's, Shayla, Kari, Scott, Michelle, Mt Tabor, Green Room, White Eagle, Ash Creek, Saturday Market, Willie Week are all saying is what matters is a good time, 3 chords, and the truth. We're truly blessed in Portland to have a vibrant independent music scene, and a supportive community. It is simple as that. Seems Morgan/Eric/Amy's point is let's not make it complicated. More good songs, less second-guessing. I'm all for that.

 

 
 

Web Design for magazines

Close
Close
Close