Monday, February 13

See That Wieden+Kennedy Super Bowl Ad With Clint Eastwood? It Was Directed by David Gordon Green

Plus it was written by Lents poet Matthew Dickman

Movies & Television Another Super Bowl, another PR coup for Wieden+Kennedy. By overwhelming consensus, the ad agency's "... More

Feb 6, 2012 12:35 pm by Aaron Mesh  | Comments 6
 

The Dream of the 1890s is Alive in Portland

Movies & Television We don't make a habit of posting Portlandia clips, but if you don't find this funny, you have no sou... More

Feb 2, 2012 12:33 pm by Ruth Brown  | Comments 10
 

Before You Watch The Grey, Watch These Three Movies

Movies & Television With its bloody Liam Neeson-on-wolf action, blockbuster The Grey, which opens in cinemas today, is g... More

Jan 27, 2012 02:10 pm by WW Arts & Culture Staff  | Comments 1
 

Movies the Oscars Loved That We Hated

(And a few we didn't)

Movies & Television Ho hum, the 2012 Academy Award nominations are out for another year. What did we think? Here's a qui... More

Jan 25, 2012 02:44 pm by Ruth Brown  | Comments 3
 
 
 
Home · Articles · Movies · Movie Reviews & Stories · The Spartans On The CGI-Wet Rock
March 7th, 2007 AARON MESH | Movie Reviews & Stories
 

The Spartans On The CGI-Wet Rock

Thermopylae is sacrificed to special effects.

14 Comments
     
Tags:
Only the hard and the strong can call themselves Spartan," the narrator of 300 intones as the red-robed troops march off to battle. And then, in case anyone in the audience was blowing her nose, or suffering from narcolepsy, he adds: "Only the hard. Only the strong."

It turns out that the people of Greece have just one weakness: repetition. "No retreat," announces their King Leonidas. "No surrender. That is Sparta." Actually, that's a Bruce Springsteen song, but sure, I guess it can also be Sparta. After all, these are the people who minted that whole return with your shield or on it bit, and they did send 300 of their finest warriors to the Battle of Thermopylae to hold off Xerxes' vastly superior Persian forces in 480 B.C. I don't think Xerxes was in fact employing a gargantuan rhinoceros, several homicidal mutants and an executioner who moonlighted as Lobster Boy—but that's Frank Miller for you, and he wrote the graphic novel 300, so there's no sense quibbling.

The trouble with 300, not to put too fine a point on it, it that it contains no sense at all. The sacrifice at Thermopylae has, over the years, been refitted as a symbol for many purposes. (Personally, I'm inclined toward the poet A.E. Houseman's resigned take: "And he that stands will die for nought, and home there's no returning./ The Spartans on the sea-wet rock sat down and combed their hair.") But director Zack Snyder (who last helmed the Dawn of the Dead remake) uses the tale the same way every action movie uses a story in the digital age: as an excuse for spectacular effects. Perhaps the only director to avoid kowtowing to his graphics has been Robert Rodrieguez, whose adaptation of another Miller comic, Sin City, preferred style to grandiosity. The burnished CGI on display is certainly jaw-dropping, with literal waves of bodies and arrows blackening the sky, but each visual crescendo is piled atop another crescendo, and the end effect is numbing. The plot of 300 doesn't so much build as it hypertrophies.

The movie is not without its virtues. It is, if nothing else, the first film in some time to recognize the ancient definitions of honor in all their unsentimental power, with no regard for modern qualms about violence. (Nobody here is dying for 21st-century lingo.) But everything good about it is sacrificed to the technical wizardry. And what's more distressing is that the laborious nature of the effects has seeped into every aspect of the filmmaking. Nothing here is gracefully offhand; it all looks like damned hard work—difficult to the point of silly. Everyone from the fight choreographer to the music composer to Leonidas himself (a well-oiled Gerard Butler) is repeatedly sweating and straining. There's no room for grace or entertainment when all hands are pushing so manfully. Only the hard is allowed—and the Spartans don't even have the dignity to comb their hair.


300 is rated R. It opens Friday at Pioneer Place, St. John's Twin Cinema-Pub, Eastport, Division, Oak Grove, Cedar Hills, Cornelius, Evergreen, Hilltop, Sandy, Sherwood, Wilsonville, Cinema 99, Cinetopia, Citer Center, Vancouver Plaza.
 
  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
 
 
 

 

 
03.08.2007 at 12:51 Reply
....back when i was a 4th grader, i enjoyed reading 'Greek Mythology' and watching the occasional Ray Harryhausen clay-mation cyclops' movie.

Too bad that this story about a real battle was given this kind of treatment, as it had....

....Mel Gibson written all over it!

 

03.08.2007 at 05:23 Reply
They probably did not tell you that Spartans were pedophile slavers and that man Greeks fought on the side of Persians in 4th grade.

This is another subliminal brainwash movie to get us ready for another war. See what the real Greeks think about this historically inaccurate bigoted spin on their history:

http://www.iht.com/articles/ap/2007/03/08/arts/EU-A-E-MOV-Greece-300.php

By ancient Persia, they refer to modern Iran whose soldiers are portrayed as bloodthirsty, underdeveloped zombies, he wrote. They are stroking racist instincts in Europe and America.

Please don't subsidize bigotry.

 

03.09.2007 at 08:05 Reply
....what i had read about 'The Battle' had been published in 1962 or earlier....

[i couldn't afford the .10 cents for a comic book at that time, nor will i pay plus 90x that for a comic book version today..(you know?)..now that i can afford to]

....and read from books that i could check out from a school library.

It ain't that guy wearing a tin foil hat that you've got to worry about today...Ray.

It's the one with snakes for hair, so be careful not to stare....

....'butt'...then again, you probably already knew that!

Huh?..."A Smart Ass!"

....or is it that your ass is smart'n from your own history lesson?"

 

03.09.2007 at 11:21 Reply
Black guys are once again the baddies, and white guys are the good guys with noble spirits. Trite cliches. But the whole movie is also full of other sexual cliches. See the Village Voice review for a full catalog of cliches.

 

03.09.2007 at 01:02 Reply
"As long as your 'Fanny is happy with a Foodstamp'

[It's still "don't ask,don't tell" for the warrior of today]

So..heY! if you'd prefer to...RatherNotSay?

"Go ahead, give some head and enjoy your day, tough guy....

 

 
 

Web Design for magazines