Tuesday, February 14

Sam Adams is on Yelp

News The other day I noticed a curious tweet from our venerable mayor's Twitter account:Yes, Sam is tweet... More

Feb 13, 2012 01:20 pm by RUTH BROWN  | Comments 1
 

Doctor Groups Flex Muscle In Capitol: $2.3 Million in Campaign Cash to Influence Health-Care Reform

News The State Capitol has been abuzz the last couple of days because of a hot list (PDF) circulating in ... More

Feb 10, 2012 06:00 pm by NIGEL JAQUISS  | Comments 4
 

Nonsense Knows No State Boundary: Washington Legislators Get Bogus Job Claims on CRC

News Up north of here, Washington legislators in Olympia are debating whether or not they should authoriz... More

Feb 10, 2012 09:09 am  | Comments 1
 

Occupy Arrestees Win Their Right to Full Trials—Even Though They May Not Need It

News The estimated 160 people arrested during Occupy Portland protests in the past five months have won t... More

Feb 9, 2012 01:24 pm by HANNAH HOFFMAN  | Comments 3
 
 
 
Home · Articles · News · Rogue of the Week · Stu Stein
January 23rd, 2008 WW Editorial Staff | Rogue of the Week
 

Stu Stein

We hate reheated leftovers.

16 Comments
     
Tags:

Plagiarism can really ruin a meal.

Just ask the furious foodies and bloggers at portlandfoodanddrink.com about Stu Stein , the chef and owner of Terroir Restaurant and Wine Bar on Northeast Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd. They’ve collected another heaping round of allegations that Stein is plagiarizing websites and newspapers to find blurb-ilicious content for his own upscale Northwest restaurant’s website (terroirportland.com).

And their record shows he didn’t steal any old junk. Among many outrages, he looks to have plagiarized two of the nation’s most prominent restaurant critics—The New York Times ’ Frank Bruni and the San Francisco Chronicle ’s Michael Bauer—in hyping his own eatery.

One description on Terroir’s website nearly matches two sentences from Bauer’s 2006 review of a restaurant called Terzo. (To see that comparison and many more, as chronicled by WW critic Heidi Yorkshire and reported on portlandfoodanddrink.com by local writer Kevin Allman, see below or go to portlandfoodanddrink.com.)

“That’s funny,” Bauer told the Rogue Desk. “I guess I’m ambivalent. I mean, it’s very lazy and very unprofessional on his part.”

Stein didn’t return messages seeking comment, and his representative at Randall Public Relations didn’t either. The kerfuffle is just the latest serving of plagiarism accusations against Stein. As a guest writer for the Ashland Daily Tidings , in 2005, Stein was caught copying portions of Tami Parr’s Pacific Northwest Cheese Project blog. That same year, a news editor removed his radio show, Sustainable Kitchen, from Jefferson Public Radio after listeners said Stein’s commentaries mirrored material in blogs and food reviews.

Stein later moved to Portland, opening Terroir in June .

“That’s doubly egregious,” Bauer said when told that history. “I can see why people are so mad.”

From the “about” section of Terroir website’s:

“It’s a copasetic blend of good design and focused intent.”

And: “A place that will convince you that small plates, civilized dining and reasonably priced food can coexist.”

»From Bauer’s June 2006 review of Terzo in the San Francisco Chronicle :

“Terzo is perfect for its Cow Hollow neighborhood, with a copasetic blend of good design and focused intent.”

And: “Terzo has renewed my enthusiasm, proving that small plates, civilized dining and reasonably priced food can coexist.”

Terroir’s site states that they “play [sic] clean, pure homage to nature’s remarkable bequests,” exactly the words used by New York Times restaurant critic Frank Bruni to describe chef Dan Barber’s Blue Hill at Stone Barns. Well, almost exactly the words: Rich wrote “pay homage,” not the nonsensical “play homage.”

»Seattle Times wine critic Paul Gregutt wrote that the expression of terroir comes “from an ongoing process of discovery, stewardship and passionate art,” a sentiment also found on Terroir’s own site.

»As Cascadia restaurant in Seattle describes itself on its own website, it is “a respite from the elements when cloudy and cool, a celebration when sunny and warm,” and “a place to enjoy the company of one or to share with many.” So says Terroir.

»At North Pond restaurant in Chicago, “We believe it important to link concern for sustainable cuisine to the pleasures of everyday fine dining.” They think the same thing at Terroir...exactly.

»At Taste restaurant, in the Seattle Art Museum, “We believe that we have the power and responsibility to make a true difference.” Terroir does, too.

 
  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
 
 
 

 

 
01.23.2008 at 01:38 Reply
First, who cares if Terroir used similar or identical phrases from other reviews or newspapers for it's website content - are the reviews or other websites even copyrighted? I noticed Terroir's was not. Second, where is the proof, not conjecture, that Mr. Stein was the one actually responsible for the content - maybe it was someone working with or for the PR firm or the website design firm. And third, with the less than glowing review in November, and now this, it raises valid concerns as to the objectivity of Ms. Yorkshire's earlier rant - I mean, review. And what is the real reason why Mr. Stein is in your cross hairs anyway? Find a different cause and write about something that really matters.

 

01.23.2008 at 04:17 Reply
Looks like Greg B. has very little company in his effort to circle the wagons. To answer your question though Greg B. about who cares, well certainly quite a few people care. The article in San Fransisco has generated plenty of response as has the discussion over at PFD... so yes it does matter and judging from Terroir being closed this evening and the fact Stu is hiding from the media and refusing to stand up and answer or accept responsibility for his restaurant and what goes on with it wether it be online or not... it would appear that even ol' boy Stu seems to sense that it MATTERS.

 

01.23.2008 at 05:28 Reply
Plagiarism is plagiarism. I assume Greg you've been to college...

 

01.24.2008 at 05:31 Reply
BS
Greg B.

Yes, those reviews are copyrighted and it is plagiarism. The copyright symbol does not need to be displayed. You create it and its yours. As a freelance creative I know a little something about copyright and understand how it damages you when your work is "stolen" by others.

And you ignore that he has been caught in the past stealing others work.

 

01.24.2008 at 05:39 Reply
Uh, Greg, aren't you a LAWYER?

 

 
 

Web Design for magazines

Close
Close
Close