Clackamas County Releases Investigative Report On Complaint Against Ludlow and Smith

Investigator didn't believe Ludlow and Smith denials

Clackamas County Chairman John Ludlow

The Clackamas County Board of Commissioners this afternoon released a 15-page investigative report (PDF) conducted in response to a workplace complaint filed by a now-former county lobbyist against County Chair John Ludlow and Commissioner Tootie Smith.

As WW reported last week, the complaint, filed by former county staff lobbyist Jared Anderson in April, alleged that he Smith discriminated against him because of his age (he is 35) and sexual orientation (he is gay). He also charged that Ludlow improperly shared personal information about Anderson's health.

After an investigation by Dana Sullivan, a Portland employment lawyer, cleared Ludlow and Smith of wrongdoing. Following that result, Anderson left the county and received a $43,775 severance payment.

Initially, the county rejected requests from WW and The Oregonian for a copy of Sullivan's investigative report but today, county officials changed their mind and released the report.

It's easy to see why they didn't want the public to read it.

Although Sullivan found that Smith had not discriminated against Anderson because of his relative youthfulness, Sullivan's wrote that Smith, who is running for Congress in Oregon's Fifth District, probably wasn't telling the truth.

"In her interview, Commissioner Smith attributed references to Mr. Lyons [another county lobbyist] and Mr. Anderson being young and inexperienced to others," Sullivan wrote. "I did not find this assertion credible."

One of the most inflammatory accusations Anderson made is that Ludlow attributed former County Commissioner Ann Lininger's getting appointed to an open Oregon House seat was LIninger's alleged
"sticking out her perky titties out in people's faces."

Ludlow told Sullivan Anderson's accusation was wrong. "Chair Ludlow denied making any remark about former Commissioner Lininger," Sullivan wrote.

But Sullivan didn't believe him, either. "I did find there is ample substantiation to conclude that Chair Ludlow made the alleged remark about former Commissioner Lininger," she wrote.

After releasing the investigative file, the commission voted unanimously to endorse a public statement Chair Ludlow read affirming the commission's commitment to diversity and inclusion:

Here's that statement:

WWeek 2015

Willamette Week’s reporting has concrete impacts that change laws, force action from civic leaders, and drive compromised politicians from public office. Support WW's journalism today.