City

Consultant Says Keller Auditorium Should Not Be Renovated

The report, which recommends an arts center at PSU, adds fire to a yearslong debate about which group should get public money to build a Broadway show-size theater.

Elphaba (Lauren Samuels) in Wicked staged in 2024 at the Keller Auditorium. (Joan marcus)

A city of Portland-commissioned report on what type of venue would best support Broadway shows in Portland has recommended that the city back a plan by Portland State University to build a new performing arts center, rather than redevelop the Keller Auditorium.

The Jan. 23 report, by Hunden Partners based in Chicago, gives the city an independent opinion on which option it should pursue: an entire redevelopment of the Keller, a concept backed by a handful of downtown property developers and longtime philanthropists, or an entirely new performing arts center built by Portland State University in downtown.

The City Council in 2024 recommended pursuing both ideas (funding has not been secured for either project, let alone both). But Hunden says Portland’s entertainment ecosystem “lacks market demand for two venues capable of large-scale, ‘Broadway-style’ productions; comparing Portland to other comparable cities does not justify two venues.”

Hunden recommended building the PSU facility, finding that the university site “is better equipped to accommodate the necessary seating and amenities, maximizing Broadway content and maintaining a theatre-style commercial presence.”

Redevelopment of the Keller, by contrast, would “not be able to meet the recommended number of seats to encourage more attendance or provide needed amenities to support modern Broadway tours,” Hunden said.

Portland State University’s vision is a sprawling performing arts center on Southwest Lincoln Street and 3rd Avenue, outfitted with a 3,000-seat auditorium, a high-end hotel, classrooms and a plaza.

The report, which in and of itself will not determine what the City Council and Mayor Keith Wilson decide, is sure to upset backers of the Keller renovation, led by downtown property owner John Russell.

Russell has aggressively lobbied for the Keller redevelopment in recent years with elected officials at the city and at the regional government Metro in a battle that has often been one-sided but has grown increasingly charged.

Russell told WW in an email that he was upset that Hulden was “unaware of the massive study of the Keller” that was funded by private donations, but also city and Metro money, in 2024. That study said it was feasible to renovate the Keller.

“It’s astonishing that the consultant was so ignorant of such an extensive project done with Metro and the City,” Russell wrote.

Meanwhile, PSU president Ann Cudd praised the city.

“The city’s market study affirms the Performing Arts + Culture Center is an incredible opportunity to fuel Portland’s future,” Cudd said in a statement.

Correction: A previous version of this story incorrectly stated that PSU’s venue would be built at the South Park Blocks. WW regrets the error.

Sophie Peel

Sophie Peel covers City Hall and neighborhoods.

Willamette Week’s reporting has concrete impacts that change laws, force action from civic leaders, and drive compromised politicians from public office.

Support WW