Schools

As PPS Pushes Forward on School Closures, Governor Seems to Ease Off

Despite PPS officials asking the governor to tap the state’s Education Stability Fund for pension relief, Kotek has no such plans.

Gov. Tina Kotek on election night. (Thomas Patterson)

Stories worth knowing. Reporting worth supporting. Willamette Week's biggest fundraiser of the year is underway. Help fund independent reporting that is free for everyone.

Give today. Keep the stories coming.

Amid Portland Public Schools’ release of a contentious final recommendation to close 10 of its 45 elementary schools, protesting families have latched onto messages from state and local elected officials who have pushed for the district to slow down.

In the weeks after PPS released two potential scenarios for closure, both Oregon Gov. Tina Kotek and the full Portland City Council sent letters to decision makers at PPS urging the district to conduct a more transparent and thorough process. All 12 city councilors signed on to a call for the district to pause before it issues a final decision.

While Kotek hasn’t gone so far, she wrote in an Oct. 13 letter, first reported by The Oregonian, that PPS should take its time to get the decision right. (Her reelection opponent, state Sen. Christine Drazan, R-Canby, sent out a campaign message pledging to Portland parents, “We’re going to keep your local neighborhood schools open.”)

PPS has nevertheless pushed forward. The Portland School Board is set to vote on Superintendent Dr. Kimberlee Armstrong’s final recommendation Dec. 15, even as parents are increasingly vocal about their concerns with underlying data backing the district’s rationale.

And while elected officials were vocal in the weeks leading up to Armstrong’s recommendation, none of them appear to have immediate plans to follow up on the district’s established decision-making timeline.

Those elected officials put pressure on PPS in the earlier stages of the process—notably ahead of consequential state and local elections—but some have since backed down. At the very least, it appears several are accepting that the decision is out of their hands.

The last time Kotek publicly commented on Portland school closures was at a press conference on Nov. 6, the day after comfortably sailing to a second term as governor. At that conference, she said she expects districts to articulate clearly what the trade-offs around school closures would be, and particularly said that PPS “needs to do everything they possibly can” to cut administrative costs and explore other options before closing schools.

“I think their process has been faulty and people are concerned,” Kotek said. “Make the case is this is going to be better for students. I think they really are failing that test at the moment.”

Yet, in response to WW’s questions about whether the governor had plans to intervene further in the outcome of Portland school closures, a spokesperson said the governor, while consistent in her positions on the subject, ultimately “understands that this is a decision that must be made by the Portland Public Schools Board.”

Eddie Wang, chair of the Portland School Board, says he has not heard anything further from Kotek since her Oct. 13 letter.

The Nov. 6 press conference also came just days after PPS officials unveiled more information surrounding a $65 million budget deficit they face for the upcoming school year. Two-thirds of that budget gap comes from rising pension costs, PPS chief financial officer Michelle Morrison said.

The district put pressure on Kotek and state legislators in early November to tap the Education Stability Fund, which holds more than $1 billion (the fund is meant to fund public education through economic instability), asking that state leaders pull out $500 million to provide pension relief to districts. Morrison has said that if the state provided such relief, the district’s budget gap would shrink to $42.7 million.

In order to access dollars from that rainy day fund, three-fifths of the Legislature must approve doing so, under the condition that one or more economic indicators are met, or that the governor declares an emergency.

Kotek expressed no interest in declaring one on Nov. 6, a position her office confirmed she still holds. She noted then that the state might reconsider whether using enrollment was the correct marker to fund schools.

“The Educational Stability Fund was set up at a time when we had significant budget deficits at the state where we could not fund our schools,” Kotek said. “That is not the situation for every school district across the state. To tap the one-time reserves for this particular instance goes against what we are talking about around enrollment driving state investment.”

In response to an inquiry from WW following Armstrong’s final recommendation, City Councilor Elana Pirtle-Guiney, a co-author of the letter the council sent last month, said she continues to believe that families deserve clear and transparent information.

“I am currently drafting a proposal that the city could pursue to support Portland families no matter what decisions the PPS board makes,” she said.

Joanna Hou

Joanna Hou covers education. She graduated from Northwestern University in June 2024 with majors in journalism and history.

Willamette Week reports the stories worth knowing, from City Hall to the people and places shaping Portland.

Help keep the stories coming by supporting WW on Give!Guide.