Dr. Know

On What Date Was Thanksgiving Originally Held?

The second Thanksgiving marked the quashing of the Whiskey Rebellion.

Freedom From Want by Norman Rockwell.

Stories worth knowing. Reporting worth supporting. Willamette Week's biggest fundraiser of the year is underway. Help fund independent reporting that is free for everyone.

Give today. Keep the stories coming.

Thanksgiving was created to celebrate a bountiful harvest. Well, harvest season is in September! America observed Thanksgiving in October until it was moved long ago. (I’ve heard vague explanations for this, similar to excuses for changing the clocks twice a year.) On what date was Thanksgiving originally held, and why was it moved to November? —Make Thanksgiving Great Again

Allow me to offer you some constructive criticism, MTGA: You’re full of shit. (Glad I could help!) Even in the early days of the republic, the U.S. has never observed a presidentially proclaimed national day of gratitude in October. The first such day was declared by George Washington in 1789 (can’t get much earlier than that) and was celebrated on—drum roll, please—the fourth Thursday in November.

That day of thanksgiving was actually supposed to be a one-off thanking God for smiting the British in the Revolutionary War. Washington proclaimed a second day of Thanksgiving in 1795 (this time in February) to mark the quashing of the Whiskey Rebellion. A third was declared by James Madison in April 1815, celebrating America’s victory in the War of 1812.

Given this post-win pattern, it was pretty ballsy of Abraham Lincoln to proclaim our fourth national day of thanksgiving before the Civil War was even over, but he did, in April 1862. He did it again—twice!—in 1863, and for the second of those he copied Washington’s choice of the last Thursday in November. Thus began the tradition he and his successors would follow every year thereafter.

So you can blame Washington for T-Day’s late arrival—but in fairness, he thought he was scheduling a day of meditation, not an orgy of gluttony. Early national days of thanksgiving were somber, pious affairs that had very little to do with eating until your eyes fall out.

However, there was a regional New England tradition of harvest festivals, also called thanksgivings, that did include feasting. (And yes, they often happened in October—but you said “America,” not “Massachusetts.”) You can see where this is going, but the two traditions didn’t combine into capital-T Thanksgiving until the late 19th century.

It was even later when Thanksgiving began to be identified with the tale of the so-called first Thanksgiving—Pilgrims, Indians, buckle-y hats. That grammar-school mainstay didn’t really take off until the 20th century, after the discovery that you can draw a turkey by tracing the outline of your hand. Next week: Oregon ruins Thanksgiving!


Questions? Send them to dr.know@wweek.com.

Marty Smith

Marty Smith is the brains (or lack thereof) behind Dr. Know and skirts the fine line between “cultural commentator” and “bum” on a daily basis. He may not have lived in Portland his whole life, but he’s lived in Portland your whole life, so don't get lippy. Send your questions to dr.know@wweek.com and find him on Twitter at @martysmithxxx.

Willamette Week reports the stories worth knowing, from City Hall to the people and places shaping Portland.

Help keep the stories coming by supporting WW on Give!Guide.