The need for strong, independent local journalism
is more urgent than ever. Please support the city we
love by joining Friends of Willamette Week.

In Cities Outside Portland, Scooters Were Banned, Thrown in the Ocean or Smeared With Poop. They Kept Going.

Angry bureaucrats, scooter bans and public backlash—sometimes scatological.

Scooters arrived in Portland in a carefully crafted arrangement with City Hall. That's in part because scooter companies tried gate-crashing in other cities—and ran into trouble.

The startups took an aggressive approach, mirroring how ride-hailing giant Uber flouted Portland rules by offering rides in 2014. The result? Angry bureaucrats, scooter bans and public backlash—sometimes scatological.

Santa Monica, Calif.

When they launched: September 2017

What happened: Santa Monica is the hometown of scooter startup Bird. The company deployed its e-scooters last fall—and weeks later, the city sued. Bird paid $300,000 in fines and secured permits. This summer, the city began voting on regulations, including which companies would be given permits and how many scooters would be allowed.

Current status: A city council committee recommended two companies—Lyft and Jump—be permitted to operate scooters. People actually showed up to protest last week because Bird and Lime weren't picked. The committee said it based its decision on Bird's and Lime's failure to comply with city rules.

San Francisco

When they launched: Late March

What happened: Bird, Lime and Spin all unloaded electric scooters on San Francisco sidewalks without asking permission. Backlash was swift and severe: People tossed scooters in trees or smeared them with feces. By June, city officials banned scooters, and threatened that any found on the streets would be impounded and the company would be fined $100 for each impounded machine.

Current status: Banned—for now. City Hall is expected to allow permitted companies  to return by the end of the month.

Los Angeles

When they launched: Mid-April

What happened: The city transportation department quickly issued a cease-and-desist order, since the scooters were already banned under a previous ruling on rentable bikes. But the department has no ability to impound the scooters, so they remain operational. (In nearby Venice Beach, people threw them in the ocean.)

Current status: Banned but running. The department is still voting on speed and safety rules, even as the machines keep humming along.


When they launched: Late May

What happened: On June 1, the city threatened to confiscate any scooters left on the street. They nabbed around 300. Scooter companies were fined around $40,000 and made to obtain proper permits.

Current status: Scooters are back. They must ride only on sidewalks, and must park only at bus stations.

St Paul, Minn.

When they launched: July 10

What happened: Bird put out scooters without permission. City officials demanded their removal. (Does this seem like a pattern? It is. The same drama—launch, ban, haggling over rules—played out on the streets of Milwaukee, Boston and Miami.)

Current status: The city voted to allow the scooters, as well as dockless bikes, on Aug. 1—and they were reintroduced to the city last week.


When they launched: Aug. 10

What happened: One hundred Bird scooters landed, but the city immediately issued a cease-and-desist order, telling Bird to remove the scooters and not replace them because the company didn't have a permit to leave the scooters on the sidewalk.

Current status: Banned. On Aug. 18, a 21-year-old woman was killed while riding an electric scooter rented from a local shop. The death made headlines as the first in the country—but it resulted from an allegedly intoxicated driver who overdosed on heroin moments after striking the woman and is being charged with aggravated vehicular homicide.


When they launched: They didn't. There are no scooters in Seattle.

What happened: In late April, the city of Seattle warned scooter companies they would not be permitted to launch in the city. In late July, Seattle passed permitting regulations that would make scooters possible.

Current status: No scooters yet—but if you leave Portland now and head north, you can probably get a Lime there by the end of the week.

A Comparison of the Three Machines Zipping Down Portland's Streets

Which Portland E-Scooter Is the Fastest? We Raced Them.

Three Scooter Companies Are Competing to Own Portland's Streets. Here's How They Compare.

Data Sets Show Portlanders Are Welcoming Their New Scooter Overlords

Skip's CEO Says When Deploying Scooters, It's Better to Ask For Permission Than Forgiveness

Scooters Are Making People Mad—and They Might Spur the Next Breakthrough in Transportation

Meet the Portland Citizens Who Hate Scooters the Most

We Designed the Ideal E-Scooter For Portland Streets. Here's What It Looks Like.

In Cities Outside Portland, Scooters Were Banned, Thrown in the Ocean or Smeared With Poop. They Kept Going.